Millions of people will lose Medicaid coverage. Millions of people will not have health insurance. Registering a health plan in the Affordable Care Act market will be more difficult and more expensive.
President Trump's domestic policy legislation, A large bill bill House cleared in May Moving to the Senate nowCritics say, it can also be called Obamacare. In addition to causing millions of Americans to lose coverage under Medicaid, the program is a health program for low-income and disabled people, including from the attempt by Republican allies of Mr. Trump to pass legislation in 2017 that would be the most important rollback of the ACA that would have repaid a large amount of President Barack Obama's domestic signature achievements.
One difference today is that Republicans have not described their legislation as a repeal of the ACA, and efforts in 2017 gave them control of the houses in the following year. Instead, they say the bill will only reduce “waste, fraud and abuse” in Medicaid and other government health plans.
Associate Professor of Political Science at Marquette University in Milwaukee and co-author of Obamacare Wars: Federalism: Federalism, State Politics, State Politics and Affordable Care Act, "in a sense, this is their ACA's Abolition Wishlist without promoting it as Obamacare abolition."
Rocco said the Republicans learned eight years ago that “the title of abolishing Obamacare is really bad politics.”
Democrats are trying to place a large Mr. Trump bill as an attack on American health care, just as they did with the 2017 legislation.
“They are essentially part of the Affordable Care Act,” said Rep. Frank Pallone (DN.J.). “The bill will undermine the country’s health care system.”
According to a poll by KFF, a national health information nonprofit organization, including KFF Health News, nearly two-thirds of adults have a preferential view of the ACA.
By comparison, about half also said there were major problems with waste, fraud and abuse in government health plans, including Medicaid.
House Speaker Mike Johnson said on CNN's "State of the Alliance" on May 25, "the change in the bill described its change as affecting immigrants living in the United States without authorization and "he claims to be a capable worker in Medicaid," but it doesn't work.
The program is “for the most vulnerable Americans, namely pregnant women and young single mothers, disabled people, older people.” “They are protected in what we are doing because we are retaining resources for those who need it most.”
The Congressional Budget Office estimated at the time that the 2025 legislation would not delve into health plans as in the way that failed 2017 bills would result in about 32 million Americans losing coverage. By contrast, the A Large Beauty Act, which affects Medicaid and ACA participants, will leave nearly 9 million people without health insurance by 2034.
The CBO said if Congress does not expand premium subsidies for the Obamacare program that have been strengthened during the pandemic to help more people buy insurance in the government market. Without Congressional action, more generous subsidies will expire at the end of the year, and most ACA participants will see their premiums rise sharply.
The increased financial aid has led to 24 million people receiving the ACA market plan this year, and health insurance experts predict a significant reduction without enhanced subsidies.
Katie Keith, founding director of the Center for Health Policy and Law at Georgetown University, said it would be devastating to lose these enhanced subsidies, combined with other changes in the House bill. ”
Republicans believe that ACA subsidies are a different issue from a large bill and accused Democrats of confusing it.
The bill run by the House also made many ACA changes, including a month shortening of the one-month annual public enrollment period and abolishing the policy from Joe Biden's presidency, which led many low-income people to sign throughout the year.
The new paperwork is also expected to cause people to fall or lose ACA coverage, the CBO said.
For example, the bill will end most automatic re-glows, which are used by more than 10 million people this year. Instead, most ACA participants are required to provide updated information to the federal and state ACA markets annually, including income and immigration status, starting in August, just before public registration.
Sabrina Corlette, a research professor and co-director of the Center for Health Insurance Reform at Georgetown University, said the study showed that additional administrative barriers have caused people to abandon coverage.
“People not only exit the process, but tend to drop out of school with healthier, younger, low incomes,” she said. “It’s stupid because they don’t have insurance. Plus, it’s bad for the insurance market.”
Supporters of the provision say it is necessary to combat fraudulent enrollment by ensuring that ACA beneficiaries still want to be insured annually or without admission without permission from Rogue sales agents. The CBO said most of the reduction in Medicaid coverage in the bill was due to new job requirements and directives for 21 million adults added to the program since 2014 under the expansion of the ACA mandate.
A new requirement is that these beneficiaries demonstrate eligibility every six months, rather than once a year, which is the norm in most states.
That will increase costs in states and could lead to people who are still eligible to leave Medicaid, said Emma Sandoe, director of Medicaid. Oregon has one of the most liberal ongoing eligibility policies that allow anyone over 6 to continue for up to two years without reapplying.
Sando said the policies help ensure that people don’t fall off for paperwork reasons and reduce the administrative burden on the state. The need for more frequent qualification checks will “limit people’s ability to access care and receive health services, which is our primary goal,” Sando said.
The 2017 abolishment effort aims to fulfill the promises made in Mr. Trump’s first presidential campaign. This is not the case now. Instead, the House bill's health policy provisions would help offset the cost of extending the tax cuts of about $4 trillion, which biases wealthier Americans.
The bill's Medicaid changes will reduce federal spending on the program by about $700 billion over a decade. The CBO has not yet issued an estimate of how much the ACA regulations will save.
Timothy McBride, a health economist at Washington University in St. Louis, said the Republican efforts to make "body-healthy" adults receive Medicaid more difficult, which is the code to reduce Obamacare.
McBride said the ACA's Medicaid expansion has been adopted by work requirements for the House bill in 40 states and Washington, D.C., and added eligibility checks to expel Medicaid participants who Republicans believe will never join the program. Congress approved the ACA in 2010 without a Republican vote.
Research shows that most Medicaid workers under the age of 65 are already working. The researchers say that imposing a requirement for people to prove they are working, or that they have to work and stay on Medicaid will lead to some people losing coverage simply because they are not filling out paperwork.
Manatt Health estimates that through the ACA expansion, about 30% of people will lose coverage, or about 7 million people.
The bill will also make it harder for people recruited under the Medicaid expansion to access care, as it requires states to charge up to $35 for certain specialist services that earn above federal poverty levels, and $15,650 for individuals in 2025.
These days, it’s rare in Medicaid, and when states charge them, they are usually nominal, usually under $10. Research shows that cost sharing in Medicaid results in poorer care opportunities among beneficiaries.
Christopher Pope, a senior fellow at the conservative Manhattan Academy, acknowledged that some people would lose coverage but rejected the notion that Republican bills constitute a full-scale attack on the ACA.
He questioned the CBO's lower coverage forecast, saying the agency often strives to accurately predict how states will respond to changes in the law. He said some states may make it easy for enrollers to meet new job requirements, reducing coverage losses.
By contrast, the ACA abolishment efforts of Mr. Trump’s first term in his ten years ago would end the entire Medicaid expansion, the pope said. "The bill does not prevent Obamacare's highest feature," the pope said.
But McBride said that while fewer people are expected to lose health insurance under the Republican bill than the 2017 estimate, it will still eliminate half of the ACA's coverage, which has brought uninsured interest rates to historical lows. "This will take us backwards," he said.
KFF Health News It is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues, KFF - Independent sources of health policy research, polls and journalism.