Traditionally, the team is divided into two camps until the MLB trade deadline - those who get talent and those who trade. But, in 2022, the third Universal Card team was added to each league, which created a 12-team playoff field, which helped develop a third category: Opportunists.
These clubs are on the verge of a feud, aiming to capitalize on thin trade markets by putting high prices into some players, hoping desperate competitors to buy - for maximum value.
Adder. Dealer. Opportunist.
This is just one of many development conditions that will help form the trade market in 2025. Let's look at all X factors that will dominate this July 31 deadline based on what executives in the league say.
1. There may be more opportunists this year.
The Milwaukee Brewers hover around the .500 in an absolutely stacked National League, and while they may be within the July lead range, it would be hopeless if the Chicago Cubs continue to build on their strong start. Additionally, it may be unlikely that the NL in the East would be crowded with playoff teams – the New York Mets, the Philadelphia Phillies and the Atlanta Braves in the East, as well as the Los Angeles Dodgers, San Diego Padres, the San Francisco Giants and the Arizona Giants and the Arizona Diamond Backpack in the West – West – This is Milwaukee’s point. According to Fangraphs, brewers have a chance to occupy the NL center (13%) (13%) (5.3%).
This could lead to what winemakers did last year on the trade deadline for trade deadlines – leveraging few dealers on the market. Freddy Peralta has been one of the league’s best starters this year, earning a very affordable $8 million this year, with Milwaukee having $8 million in options next season. If the orioles land on him, he will immediately become their ace. For the Yankees, he might be the cornerstone behind Max Fried and Carlos Rodon. If Peralta stays healthy, his value will never be higher than it is now.
The Rays were an opportunist last summer, flipping Randy Arozarena to the Seattle Mariners, despite the remaining two and a half years of team control and trade handed over to the Cubs with Isaac Paredes, though only trailing the third wildcard 1.5 games on the last Sunday of July. Tampa Bay has not entered the full-selling mode; instead, it sees a distinct trade market - "No OK "It's OK for players to use," an executive said in mid-July last year.
Brewers won't choose this path. Owner Mark Attanasio is seen as competitive by his peers and he has great value in the playoffs. Some rival executives don’t think Milwaukee’s Peralta would consider a deal if the team is still within the Cubs, and the Cubs are managed by former Milwaukee manager Craig Counsell.
But for some team competitors, this is something worth considering:
St. Louis Cardinals: They're in a winning streak, they've already communicated with other teams, and even if they're not the leader, they might keep their tradeable players in their final season as John Mozeliak's head of baseball business.
Minnesota Twins: They can hang Byron Buxton in a trade conversation. Buxton was healthy and well-behaved, and he signed a contract for $15.1 million a year for the next three seasons.
Toronto Blue Jays: Now that they have signed Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
One executor working for competitors doesn’t think the opportunist list will be long.
“Often, what they ask for is unrealistic,” he said. “They ask for four best prospects for you, you say no, they keep moving forward and keep the players.”
2. The general mediocrity of the American alliance can greatly reduce the number of its dealers.
The Chicago White Sox is rebuilding and opening, but the front desk of any other team in AL can convince the playoff bid to be possible - because there seems to be very few (if any).
The Baltimore Orioles may be the best example of this phenomenon. The start of the season was disastrous for Baltimore, with Baltimore’s rotation being beaten up frequently. But given their success over the past two seasons and on the roster of young players, it’s hard to imagine the Orioles surrender early. So even if their record fails, they may be a club that is reluctant to separate from their talent by the deadline.
3. Teams that are already seen as potential subtractors may not have what competitors want.
In the eyes of rival assessors, clubs like the Colorado Rockies, Miami Marlins and the White Sox don’t have much to offer. Other teams have already spyed on the Marlins, right-wing Sandy Alcantara and white sox outfielder Luis Robert Jr., but both are struggling early this season. Alcantara has 8.42 ERA in seven games since he returned from elbow surgery, while Robert's early slash line was .186/.293/.326, which doesn't promote interest from other teams - nor is it the White Sox leverage.
4. It seems that the outfielder market will be very thin.
Typically, the upcoming free agent class is a tool that defines most players who can trade before that year's deadline - in short, in the outfield, there are few pickers outside of Kyle Tucker.
Potential opportunists can take advantage of a very soft outfield market where they get value if they are willing to hang outfielders under the control of a team outside of the season. For example, the twins could set a steady price for Buxton, and Jays might have a lot of interest for Daulton Varsho, an elite defender who wouldn't be eligible for free agents until after the 2026 season.
5. Few good start pitchers are expected.
There may be some interest if the Cardinal decides to date Erick Fedde, who has a 3.86 ERA this season. Right-handed starter Sonny Gray is a three-time All-Star game, but his contract is very late-loaded – he owed $35 million in 2026 – was last traded to the mid-contender (from track and field in 2017 to the New York Yankees), but it wasn't going well.
6. Nolan Arenado's trade is still possible.
If Arenado waives his no-trade terms, the conditions are promoting this possibility and If the Cardinal is willing to trade with him. Usually, moving money in the middle of the season is not easy for a player, but contenders may be interested in getting eight All-Star third baseman. The Cubs found no solution at third base and the Yankees will soon try DJ Lemahieu to keep filling the post. The Los Angeles Dodgers waited for Max Munchy to turn and start last season, and he finally did it. This year, they waited again.
Arenado killed a possible deal to the Houston Astros last winter, owing about $24 million for the rest of the year, $27 million in 2026 ($5 million paid by the Rockies) and $15 million in 2027.