Donald Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. It also includes citation errors, such as authors attributed to errors in research.
To make things worse, the report appears to have been written using artificial intelligence. Washington Post. The revelation comes weeks after the Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Kennedy touted the department’s commitment to free use of AI.
Kennedy told lawmakers earlier this month: “The AI revolution has arrived.” He said: “We are very, very active in implementing AI,” he added: “We bring very high-quality caliber people from Silicon Valley.” Kennedy promises to use AI to speed up clinical trials for drug testing and provides people with a way to avoid going to emergency rooms in rural areas with shortages.
"Maha Report: Make Our Kids Healthy Again", researching diet, technology use, medication use, and other factors that help children's health. The report believes that the key consequence of child health problems is that most people are unable to serve in the military, mainly due to obesity, poor physical health and/or mental health challenges. The report also argues that children are taking too much medication, consistent with the long-term peeling of RFK Jr., opposing vaccines and drugmakers.
The "research" of counterfeit and inferior problems has raised questions about the effectiveness of the report. Notus first pointed out many of the problems in the study, indicating that the seven cited studies do not exist. Notus also found a question about how the report explains its origins.
"The cited paper is not a real paper that I or my colleagues are involved in," epidemiologist Katherine Keyes told Notus. "We have certainly done research on this topic, but have not published the paper in JAMA pediatrics on the topic, or published it with the topic or the title."
In particular, citations show signs of AI use, postal Established. These questions go beyond typical user errors, writing some annoying APA references. For example, the URLs in both references include the word "oaiicite", which quotes Openai, postal It is called the "determination mark" that authors use AI.
The report also cites articles that do not exist. For example, “direct to consumer advertising and increased use of ADHD medications in children” sounds like a real article, but it is fabricated. The report cites an article by Robert Findling, a professor of psychiatry, on a topic he wrote, but the article does not exist. This is a sign of AI use, because the chatbot "illusion" is postal Say, citing research that may be true but is not the case.
Citations from two articles U.S. News and World Report Titled “How much rest should a kid get?” Each credit has a different author. However, both authors are the ones who actually wrote this article. The same is true for another citation on the dent. As we all know, AI chatbots mix real references with false information, often described as hallucinations.
For statistics on children with asthma, the report cites articles that appear to exist, but does not include statistics. The main author of the article in the citation is correct, but the co-author is not - another mistake.
this postal Also identified the URL that no longer works. If the AI is trained on older materials, outdated links can be included.
Another citation includes citations for reference materials, only conceptually mastering the error of citation or robots.
Rolling stones It is also noted that some citations lack italicization, while others lack capital letters, which at least implies an author without academic background, a lazy author or a robot.
On Friday, Notus found that the report was updated and added the entire new bug. since postalThe story emerged Friday night, and the White House seemed to have edited the report again to remove some of the evidence mentioned in the article. For example, “peridot” no longer appears in the report.
A HHS spokesperson told postal “The smaller citations and format errors were corrected, but the Substantiveness of the Maha Report remains the same – a historic and transformative assessment of the federal government to understand the chronic disease epidemic that has caused our country’s children to suffer.”