Black smoke emerges at Vatican as conclave fails to elect pope – as it happened | Papal conclave

Closing summary

… and on that note, it’s a wrap from me, Jakub Krupa, for today.

  • Plumes of black smoke have emerged from the chimney on top of the Sistine Chapel, signalling that the 133 cardinals sealed off inside have failed to elect a new pope on the first day of conclave (21:01, 21:21, all times in CEST).

  • The result is not unexpected (21:04) – only once in history the pope was elected on the first day, over 500 years ago.

  • The cardinals will be back for more tomorrow as the conclave continues: with up to four votes; two in the morning, two in the afternoon (21:17).

Doors to the Sistine Chapel close as Conclave begins – video

And here are our explainers to help you understand the process better:

  • How many rounds of voting are usually needed? (19:00)

  • Who are the electors? (18:35)

  • The Sistine Chapel, Santa Maria guesthouse – key locations (18:06)

  • How the voting process works? (16:52)

  • Brief history of conclaves past (16:15)

  • What’s the in-tray for the new pope (14:50)

And that’s all from me, Jakub Krupa, for today.

If you have any tips, comments or suggestions, email me at jakub.krupa@theguardian.com.

I am also on Bluesky at @jakubkrupa.bsky.social and on X at @jakubkrupa.

Share

Updated at 

Key events

Faithful react to black smoke - in pictures

Faithful react to black smoke indicating no decision has been made to elect a new pope, at the Vatican. Photograph: Eloisa Lopez/Reuters
Faithful react to black smoke rising from the chimney on the Sistine Chapel indicating no decision has been made to elect a new pope, at the Vatican. Photograph: Marko Đurica/Reuters
Faithful gathered in St. Peter's Square use their mobile phones as black smoke comes out of the chimney atop the Sistine Chapel. Photograph: Andrea Solero/EPA
Share

Black smoke signals first day of Vatican conclave has failed to elect new pope

Angela Giuffrida

Plumes of black smoke have emerged from the chimney on top of the Sistine Chapel, signalling that the 133 cardinals sealed off inside have failed to elect a new pope on the first day of conclave.

Faithful react at St Peter's Square as screen displaying footage of the chimney of the Sistine Chapel rising black smoke signalling that cardinals failed to elect a new pope. Photograph: Dimitar Dilkoff/AFP/Getty Images

After the formal procession to the Sistine Chapel and each of the cardinals swearing the oath to secrecy, the first voting round only got under way at about 5.45pm local time.

Then all eyes were on the famous chimney, which was diligently guarded by a seagull for some of the time the cardinals were voting.

After a tense wait, black smoke finally appeared at 9:05pm – to loud applause from the crowd of more than 45,000 below.

The conclave will continue on Thursday, and end only when a successor to Pope Francis, who died last month aged 88, is found.

Share

What to expect tomorrow?

Jakub Krupa
Jakub Krupa

Up to four rounds of voting tomorrow (and in the following days).

The first one is expected 9.30am local time (8.30am BST), and the second one closer to midday (11am local time).

They then will take a lunch break until 4pm, with another two rounds expected around 5.30pm and 7pm local time (4.30pm and 6pm).

For now, the electors will go back to Santa Marta guesthouse for their dinner – but will be back in the Sistine Chapel tomorrow.

Map of the Vatican City
Share

Updated at 

Black smoke from Sistine Chapel - snap analysis

Jakub Krupa
Jakub Krupa

Well, that was expected – even if took longer than we anticipated.

We have 133 cardinal electors, many of whom are new – appointed by Pope Francis – and so they don’t know each other that well.

They will understandably need more time to decide on the right person to be confirmed as the pope.

The delay is interesting, but there are so many potential reasons for it and it wouldn’t be wise to speculate.

The cardinals will be back for more votes tomorrow: up to four rounds, if needed. Two in the morning, two in the afternoon.

Share

Updated at 

Black smoke emerges at Vatican as conclave fails to elect pope

No decision in the first round of the vote.

Black smoke rises from the chimney on the Sistine Chapel, indicating no decision has been made to elect a new pope. Photograph: Yara Nardi/Reuters
Share

Updated at 

We are now well into the fourth hour since the doors to the Sistine Chapel were closed.

It’s getting darker and darker in the Vatican as thousands of faithful in St Peter’s Square and millions around the world await the result of the first vote.

People wait at St Peter's Square for smoke signalling the result of the cardinals' vote. Photograph: Andrej Isaković/AFP/Getty Images
Faithful wait for the smoke to rise from the chimney on the Sistine Chapel as conclave to elect a new Pope starts, at St Peter’s Square in The Vatican. Photograph: Jeff Pachoud/AFP/Getty Images
Share
Jakub Krupa
Jakub Krupa

A reader mails in to ask a perfectly legitimate question about the history of the Roman seagulls and how they ended up in-land.

Personally, I have no idea, but absolutely love the question.

Having said that, turns out our Rome correspondent Angela Giuffirda offers a hint of what could be the answer here in one of her recent reports from the Italian capital:

(A Rome zoologist Andrea) Lunerti said: “Rome really needs to get a grip on its waste management, otherwise we will be seeing even more snakes and hornets, not to mention the rats and seagulls – there are more seagulls in Rome than there are in Fregene (a nearby coastal town).

He said that at least the seagulls helped reduce the numbers of rats and snakes. “A snake was captured by a seagull and dropped on to a terrace,” he said. “The city has become a proper jungle.”

Last year Venice also had to briefly close its airport because of seagulls, but then that makes more sense given its location…

In any case, if anyone knows the full story of the Roman seagulls, please email me at jakub.krupa@theguardian.com.

A seagull stands on a cross while another one flies, on the first day of the conclave to elect the new pope, at the Vatican. Photograph: Remo Casilli/Reuters
Share

As we wait…

A lot of people following the real-life conclave probably watched the hit Oscar-winning movie starring Ralph Fiennes to see what to expect to happen in the next few days.

(I certainly did and, if Politico is to be believed, even some of the actual cardinals taking part in it did, too.)

Ralph Fiennes as Cardinal Thomas Lawrence in Conclave Photograph: Pictorial Press Ltd/Alamy

And my colleague Adrian Horton asked the right question:

As a deft and highly entertaining thriller on the furtive process of electing a new pope, well, you can expect people to consider Conclave as close to documentary as laypeople can get to the action. But how accurate is it?

Well, according to experts, more spot-on than not, and at the very least meticulously researched.

Here are their answers in full:

An X user even produced a helpful side-by-side clip now, if you want to compare the fiction and the reality.

Share

Updated at 

All eyes on Sistine Chapel’s chimney – in pictures

People gather on rooftops on the first day of the conclave to elect the next pope. Photograph: Alessandro Di Meo/EPA
People wait at St Peter's Square at the Vatican, on the first day of conclave to elect the new pope. Photograph: Alkis Konstantinidis/Reuters
People gather in St. Peter's Square on the first day of the conclave to elect the next pope. Photograph: Alessandro Di Meo/EPA
A seagull sits on the chimney on the Sistine Chapel roof on the first day of conclave. Photograph: Yara Nardi/Reuters
Share
Jakub Krupa
Jakub Krupa

The wait continues. I think I recognise most seagulls on this roof by now.

Share

Anticipation in the Vatican – in pictures

The faithful gather in Vatican City, Vatican. Photograph: Antonio Masiello/Getty Images
People wait to see the smoke billow from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel in St Peter’s Square during the cardinals’ conclave to elect a new pope. Photograph: Alessandra Tarantino/AP
People wait to see the smoke billowing from the chimney of the Sistine Chapel in St Peter’s Square during the cardinals’ conclave to elect a new pope. Photograph: Markus Schreiber/AP
Share

Updated at 

If you wonder about the chemistry behind the Vatican smoke, here’s our explainer from the last conclave in 2013.

Birds fly over the chimney set up on the roof of the Sistine Chapel, on the first day of the conclave to elect a new pope. Photograph: Fabio Frustaci/EPA
Share

How many votes are usually needed to elect pope?

Historically, some of the conclaves were really drawn out: in 13th century, they needed three years, over 1,000 days, to choose Gregory X.

There was also one that ended on the same day, although it started earlier in the morning: Julius II in 1503 was elected after just 10 hours.

Black smoke emerges from the chimney on the Sistine Chapel as cardinals voted on the second day of the conclave to elect a pope in St. Peter’s Square at the Vatican in 2013. Photograph: Michael Sohn/AP

But in the last 150 years, it was usually a much shorter process: the longest, for Pius XI in 1922, took 5 days.

Francis was elected on the second day in 2013, after five rounds of voting; similarly, Benedict XVI needed just four rounds to be confirmed as the new pope in 2005, as did John Paul I in 1978.

A bit more time was needed to confirm John Paul II – three days, eight rounds – in 1978, and John XXIII in 1958, with 11 votes over four days. But then his immediate predecessor, Pius XII was elected after just three rounds.

So, the recent history seems to suggest we could very well have a new pope before the weekend.

But since the process is so secretive and there are so many moving elements with a record-high number of cardinals involved in the process this year, there’s no way to predict what happens behind the closed doors.

Let’s see.

Share

As we wait for black or white smoke after the first vote, some Catholic women campaigners released pink smoke from flares, and demanded that women be allowed to seek ordination, AFP reported.

Pink smoke rises in front of St. Peter’s Dome during a protest by the Women’s Ordination Conference, calling for full equality for women in the Catholic Church on the first day of the conclave to elect the 267th pope, in Rome. Photograph: Bernat Armangué/AP

“We are saying to the cardinals, you cannot keep ignoring 50% of the Catholic population, you cannot go into a locked room and discuss the future of the Church without half of the Church,” said Miriam Duignan.

“Whoever they elect needs to be brave enough to properly tackle the question of women’s inclusion, because so far it has not been, even by Pope Francis,” said Duignan, of the Wijngaards Institute in Cambridge.

In the global church as a whole, women have begun to take some senior lay roles, a process that accelerated a little under Pope Francis’s papacy.
But even those who have studied theology and church ministry are excluded from the priesthood, and only priests hold the most senior leadership roles, AFP noted.

Share

Updated at 

Chimney camera - live stream

If you want to make sure you don’t miss the result of the first vote when it comes, here’s our live stream showing the chimney on top of the Sistine Chapel:

View of the chimney on the day of the conclave – watch live
Share

Who are the electors? - visuals

This conclave is billed as the largest and possibly the most unpredictable conclave to ever take place. So let’s take a look at the Vatican’s own statistics.

There are 133 cardinals electors (well, technically there are 135, but two were too ill to attend) from 70 countries, up from 115 from 48 nations in the last conclave in 2013.

The youngest one is Mykola Bychok, 45, from Ukraine; the oldest is Carlos Osoro Sierra, who turns 80 in less than two weeks. Those over 80 are not involved in the process.

107 of them were appointed by Pope Francis, 21 by Pope Benedict XVI, and five by Pope John Paul II.

The successful candidate needs a two-third majority, 89 votes, to get elected.

So, where do they come from?

The highest national representation comes from Italy (17) ahead of the US (10), Brazil (7), Spain and France (5 each).

Here is how it looks on the map:

Map of the world, showing where cardinals electors are from
Cardinals taking part in the conclave by the continent or country of origin, with Europe leading the way ahead of Asia.